Narrow tier2 kind-8 availability path

This commit is contained in:
Jan Petykiewicz 2026-04-19 10:59:42 -07:00
commit 14820991ca
2 changed files with 96 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,82 @@
# Runtime Effect Kind-8 Tier2 Named Availability Note
This note records the current named-candidate availability comparison between the strongest
title-overlap pair:
- `Louisiana.gmp`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp`
The comparison uses the checked `rt3_105_save_name_table_probe` surface from `inspect-smp`.
## Immediate Result
`Warehouse05` is **not** the differentiator.
Observed values:
- `Warehouse05`
- `Louisiana.gmp = 1`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp = 1`
- `Port01`
- `Louisiana.gmp = 1`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp = 1`
- `Furniture Factory`
- `Louisiana.gmp = 1`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp = 1`
- `FarmGrain`
- `Louisiana.gmp = 1`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp = 1`
- `Logging Camp`
- `Louisiana.gmp = 1`
- `Dutchlantis.gmp = 1`
So the strongest current `Louisiana -> Dutchlantis` title overlap does not also come with a unique
`Warehouse05` availability toggle that would directly explain the one-row
`Add Building Warehouse05` dispatch cluster in `Louisiana.gmp`.
## Full Named-Availability Differences
The current comparison shows `18` differing names:
- `AluminumMill`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `AutoPlant`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Bauxite Mine`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Chemical Plant`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Farm Corn`: `Louisiana = 1`, `Dutchlantis = 0`
- `FarmCotton`: `Louisiana = 1`, `Dutchlantis = 0`
- `FarmRice`: `Louisiana = 1`, `Dutchlantis = 0`
- `FarmSheep`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `FarmSugar`: `Louisiana = 1`, `Dutchlantis = 0`
- `Fertilizer Factory`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Iron Mine`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Nuclear Power Plant`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Oil Refinery`: `Louisiana = 1`, `Dutchlantis = 0`
- `Plastics Factory`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Recycling Plant`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Steel Mill`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Tool And Die`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
- `Uranium Mine`: `Louisiana = 0`, `Dutchlantis = 1`
## Current Implication
The Tier 2 candidate/world-state rebuild strip remains plausible in general because it owns named
candidate availability seeding and refresh, but the current evidence no longer supports the narrow
claim that `Louisiana.gmp` gets its `Add Building Warehouse05` row from a unique
`Warehouse05` availability difference relative to `Dutchlantis.gmp`.
Two deeper grounded notes tighten that further:
- `structure_candidate_collection_rebuild_runtime_records_from_scenario_state` `0x00412d70`
does **not** consult the scenario-side recipe-book name at `[state+0x0fe8]`; it formats the
rebuilt candidate display stem from one of two fixed built-in roots `0x005c93d8` or
`0x005c93e8` plus the current ordinal.
- `scenario_state_upsert_named_candidate_availability_record_and_refresh_runtime_filters`
`0x00434f20` now reads safely as a real boolean availability override writer rather than a wider
mode enum.
So the next Tier 2 recovery question is now tighter still:
- whether the relevant difference is in broader candidate-state rebuild sequencing, latch refresh,
or cargo-membership/runtime-record reconstruction under
`0x00437737 / 0x00412c10 / 0x00412bd0 / 0x00412d70 / 0x00412fb0`,
rather than in the direct named availability bit for `Warehouse05` itself.

View file

@ -481,6 +481,20 @@ Working rule:
port/warehouse recipe rebuild `0x00435630`, port/warehouse recipe rebuild `0x00435630`,
and only then the later world bringup / event-service neighborhood and only then the later world bringup / event-service neighborhood
`0x004384d0 / 0x00443a50 / 0x00432f40`. `0x004384d0 / 0x00443a50 / 0x00432f40`.
- the strongest same-stem title pair has a Tier 2 availability note now too:
`artifacts/exports/rt3-1.06/runtime-effect-kind8-tier2-named-availability-note.md`
shows `Louisiana.gmp` and `Dutchlantis.gmp` share the direct named-availability bit for
`Warehouse05` (`1/1`), as well as `Port01`, `Furniture Factory`, `FarmGrain`, and
`Logging Camp`; their current `18` named-availability differences fall elsewhere
(`Bauxite Mine`, `AluminumMill`, `Farm Corn`, `FarmCotton`, `FarmRice`, `FarmSugar`, etc.).
The same note now folds in two deeper grounded constraints too:
`0x00412d70` does not consult the scenario-side recipe-book name at `[state+0x0fe8]`, and
`0x00434f20` writes only a boolean availability override bit. So the current Tier 2 question
is no longer “is `Warehouse05` simply toggled differently?” or “is a recipe-book display name
leaking through?” but
“which broader candidate-state rebuild or latch sequencing difference above
`0x00437737 / 0x00412c10 / 0x00412bd0 / 0x00412d70 / 0x00412fb0` leads to the shipped
`Add Building Warehouse05` row in `Louisiana.gmp`?”
kinds”; it is the smaller set of scenario-specific records where that sweep explicitly writes kinds”; it is the smaller set of scenario-specific records where that sweep explicitly writes
`[event+0x7ef]` itself or a still-later owner does. `[event+0x7ef]` itself or a still-later owner does.
- two explicit trigger-kind materializations are now grounded inside that retagger: - two explicit trigger-kind materializations are now grounded inside that retagger: